From controlling behavior and repeated cheating to public arguments and broken trust, the 90 Day Fiance franchise has shown some truly damaging relationship patterns. These are the 10 Most Toxic Couples, ranked from bad to worst based on what viewers saw on screen and what each couple later reported publicly.
This list doesn’t suggest every franchise romance is doomed. Some couples face cultural pressure and still build healthy marriages. However, these ten relationships involved serious conflict, manipulation, dishonesty, humiliation, legal battles, or lasting family fallout.
90 Day Fiance Toxic Couples: What Makes A Relationship Toxic?
The ranking considers documented behavior from the show and reported relationship events. Control, verbal abuse, infidelity, financial deception, legal conflict, public humiliation, and damage to children or relatives all factor into the list. Private claims without supporting evidence don’t decide the ranking. Okay, but every couple here contributed to a relationship that became deeply unhealthy in its own way.
90 Day Fiance Couple No. 10: Angela Deem & Michael Ilesanmi
Angela Deem and Michael Ilesanmi met on Facebook before Angela traveled to Lagos to meet him. Their 22-year age gap created tension, but the bigger problems involved trust and control. They married in 2020 while Michael’s visa process faced long delays. Angela tried to restrict Michael’s social media use because she feared he would cheat. Michael later admitted to infidelity during the relationship. Angela also faced criticism for her verbal outbursts toward him. The couple eventually separated after Michael left her home in Georgia.
Angela filed for an annulment in June 2024 and alleged that Michael had used the marriage for immigration purposes. Michael denied those allegations and accused Angela of emotional and physical abuse. Since both partners contributed to the collapse, they rank as the least severe entry here.
90 Day Fiance Couple No. 9: Kim Menzies & Usman Umar
Kim Menzies became a fan of Usman Umar’s music before their relationship began. The couple had an 18-year age difference, and Kim traveled to Zanzibar in 2021 to meet him. Their connection quickly faced pressure from Usman’s family. His relatives wanted children and discussed the possibility of Usman taking a second wife. Kim strongly rejected that idea. The couple also clashed over culture, commitment, and attention. Kim repeatedly removed her ring and threatened to end their engagement, while Usman called the relationship “toxic.” Kim also told Usman that he needed a tummy tuck, which only added to the hurtful exchanges. They broke up in December 2022 after months of emotional pressure and incompatibility.
90 Day Fiance Couple No. 8: Sarper Guven & Shekinah Garner
Shekinah Garner met Sarper Guven on a dating app while visiting Turkey. Their long-distance romance led Shekinah to move there. Sarper claimed he had slept with more than 2,500 women and kept a record of his past partners. His behavior toward Shekinah raised constant questions about boundaries. He tried to influence her appearance, including the design of her nose job. He also controlled her phone and ripped out a hair extension during a birthday celebration shown on the series.
Shekinah responded by demanding that Sarper stop accepting female clients. His history with women made trust almost impossible. The show documented specific controlling behaviors and intense reactions without requiring viewers to diagnose either partner.
90 Day Fiance Couple No. 7: Jasmine Pineda & Gino Palazzolo
Jasmine Pineda and Gino Palazzolo met on an international dating website. After nine months of online conversations, Gino traveled to Panama, where they became engaged. Their relationship soon turned into a nonstop argument about money and trust. Jasmine demanded a $2,500 wedding dress and accused Gino of being cheap. She also hid her engagement ring after a disagreement, hoping he would buy a more expensive one. Reported cheating issues added more pressure, though those rumors were never confirmed as fact.
Gino brought his own problems to the relationship. His adult-content use contributed to intimacy issues, and he felt uncomfortable with Jasmine’s interest in adding a third person. Readers may remember our earlier story about Gino’s franchise income and finances, but the bigger issue here was how poorly this couple handled conflict. They broke up in 2023.
90 Day Fiance Couple No. 6: Danielle Mullins & Mohamed Jbali
Danielle Mullins met Mohamed Jbali in an online chat room when she was 41, and he was 26. Before Mohamed arrived in America, Danielle didn’t tell him about her serious debt and history involving credit card fraud allegations. The couple argued over intimacy, hygiene, and personal expectations. Mohamed criticized Danielle’s body odor, while Danielle accused him of avoiding intimacy. Their disagreements quickly turned into personal attacks rather than honest conversations.
Mohamed left after obtaining his green card. Danielle later pursued legal action and alleged that he had used her for immigration purposes. Their marriage became one of the franchise’s clearest examples of secrecy turning into resentment.
90 Day Fiance Couple No. 5: Chantel Everett & Pedro Jimeno
Chantel Everett met Pedro Jimeno online after a friend introduced them. She traveled to the Dominican Republic, and the couple became engaged. Chantel then lied to her family about Pedro’s visa, saying he had a student visa instead of explaining their engagement.
Both families created major problems after the truth emerged. Chantel’s relatives suspected Pedro wanted residency, but the show never established that he married her for that reason. His emotional distance and closeness with a female coworker still fueled those concerns. Pedro also fought Chantel’s brother during a heated family confrontation. He filed for divorce in May 2022, after receiving permanent residency. Their breakup continued to unfold on The Family Chantel, turning private marital pain into a family-wide conflict.
90 Day Fiance Couple No. 4: Anfisa Arkhipchenko & Jorge Nava
Anfisa Arkhipchenko and Jorge Nava entered the relationship with very different expectations about money and lifestyle. Anfisa wanted luxury, while Jorge claimed he could afford it. Their fights became explosive after they started living together.
Anfisa kicked Jorge out of their apartment, keyed his car, and demanded a $45,000 wedding dress. Those scenes showed a relationship built around anger and financial pressure. Jorge wasn’t innocent, either. He lied about his finances and later faced drug-related charges and offenses. Anfisa filed for divorce while Jorge served his sentence. Their marriage ended because neither partner offered the honesty or stability the other expected.
90 Day Fiance Couple No. 3: Karine Martins & Paul Staehle
Karine Martins and Paul Staehle met online in 2016 before Paul traveled to Brazil. Their problems started almost immediately. Paul insisted on STD and pregnancy testing before intimacy, which humiliated Karine and damaged their trust. Paul also hid his criminal history, including an arson conviction, and a former partner had filed a restraining order against him. Both partners accused each other of cheating. Their arguments eventually escalated to police involvement and restraining orders filed by both sides.
The couple divorced in 2021. Their sons, Pierre and Ethan, later became part of custody disputes, and both parents lost custody. The legal conflict and consequences for their children place this relationship near the top of the list.
90 Day Fiance Couple No. 2: Darcey Silva & Tom Brooks
Darcey Silva and Tom Brooks built a long-distance connection before meeting in the United Kingdom. Darcey felt ignored because Tom communicated inconsistently. Their problems worsened after she discovered his connection with a woman named Shannon.
During their tense New York meeting, Tom said he viewed Darcey like a “sister.” He later asked whether she had gained weight since their last meeting. The comments landed as public humiliation, especially after their already painful breakup conversation. Tom’s words and the awkward confrontation made this relationship especially cruel to watch. Their romance ended soon afterward, with no realistic path toward reconciliation.
90 Day Fiance Couple No. 1: Big Ed Brown & Rosemarie Vega
Big Ed Brown and Rosemarie Vega had a 31-year age gap when they connected through Facebook in 2019. Ed traveled to the Philippines to meet Rose, but their power imbalance became obvious from the beginning. Ed judged Rose’s family home and accused her of wanting his money. He criticized her legs, complained about her breath, and gave her mouthwash and a toothbrush. Rose explained that a stomach ulcer affected her breath, but Ed continued to focus on her appearance.
He also made repeated comments that embarrassed Rose and dismissed her feelings. Rose ended the relationship in 2020 and later accused Ed of using her for fame. This couple ranks worst because the show documented repeated humiliation, class-based judgment, and an extreme imbalance of age and power.
90 Day Fiance Fans React To The 10 Most Toxic Couples
Fans may rank these couples differently because each relationship involved a different kind of dysfunction. Some viewers may place Angela and Michael first because of the control, infidelity, and legal claims. Others may choose Paul and Karine because police involvement, restraining orders, and custody problems affected their children. Big Ed and Rose also remain a common top choice because of the insults and power imbalance. The tea is HOT, and there is no shortage of debate here.
Which 90 Day Fiance couple ranks as the most toxic?
Big Ed Brown and Rosemarie Vega take the top spot because of their documented age and power imbalance, repeated insults, and public humiliation. Ed’s treatment of Rose made their relationship especially uncomfortable to watch.
Why do Angela Deem and Michael Ilesanmi rank on the 90 Day Fiance toxic couples list?
Angela and Michael had repeated control issues, admitted infidelity, and serious trust problems. Their separation led to legal claims from Angela and abuse accusations from Michael.
Which 90 Day Fiance couples from this list are no longer together?
All ten relationships ended or faced major separation, with some breakups followed by legal disputes or continued franchise appearances. Which 90 Day Fiance couple would you rank as the most toxic?